Showing posts with label Iain Duncan-Smith. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Iain Duncan-Smith. Show all posts

Thursday, January 05, 2017

It's only a revolution if the people support it, otherwise it's just a reactionary coup...

One of the most worrying trends in recent politics is the rise of the demagogue in Western politics. It led to Brexit, and saw Donald Trump win the Presidency. Here in Britain though, it appears to be being usurped by a small bunch of highly influential ideologues.

First, it was experts. They're all biased, because they didn't agree that Brexit was the greatest thing since sliced bread. How very dare they suggest that things are complex, and that it might not be so easy, or beneficial to cut ourselves adrift from the largest single trading bloc in the world? The answer, discredit them, as the likes of Michael Gove chose to do.

By the way, what has happened to Michael since he lost his leadership bid? Has stabbing his former friends in the back caused him to lose the plot, for his use of Twitter is not that of someone behaving entirely rationally? But I digress...

By discrediting experts, the field is left open for any opinionated person with access to a media platform to make any claim they like, knowing that it will have to be given credence by repetition through an unquestioning media (yes, I'm looking at the BBC!).

And that credibility leads to influence.

But our system of government has checks and balances, through an independent judiciary and a neutral Civil Service. Well, they've got to go, haven't they? First, attack the right of the judiciary to determine what the law is (Iain Duncan-Smith, for ignominious example), leaving it to our merry band of opinionated ideologues again to define what they can get away with under the cover of leadership privilege.

And they then need a Civil Service which is unwaveringly committed to the Project. There's no need for balanced advice, or for experience, if the cause is so right, so glorious. Thus, pick new people, people who will do what they are told unquestioningly.

In such ways is our Government undermined. The cost is to our rights and freedoms, the protections from an over-mighty state in the hands of extremists. For I'm afraid that that's what the likes of Michael Gove and Iain Duncan-Smith presage, and it isn't a country for liberals or the powerless. Because, at the end of the day, it's all about taking back control, taking back control from the people and putting it in the hands of the ideologues.

That never ends well...

Monday, January 05, 2015

Has Iain Duncan-Smith conceded the General Election?

Iain Duncan-Smith is to accelerate the rollout of Universal Credit so that Labour can't scrap it, or so it is said by the Daily Telegraph.

My first thought, when Ros told me this, was, "Is that the action of a politician who expects to be in power after 7 May?". Hardly. And it isn't as though Labour are fifteen points clear in the polls, without a cloud in the sky to spoil their triumphant stroll to power. Increasingly, talk is of a hung Parliament without any clear indication of how the chips may fall. Heaven knows, I haven't a clue what the outcome will be, and certainly won't be betting my life savings on it.

And, as I've already noted, cancellation of the Universal Credit programme is not an obvious step - it offers a (potentially) genuinely innovative means of cutting the cost of welfare without having to cut benefits (sort of).

What worries me is that, in order to protect Mr Duncan-Smith's legacy, he will cause the very thing he fears most, cancellation of a project which, due to entirely unnecessary haste, ends up failing and failing badly.

Government should be about having confidence in your actions, and not about making it impossible or extremely expensive to undo your commitments. Labour demonstrated how not to do this when ordering aircraft carriers in the run-up to the 2010 election.

So, more haste, less speed, appears to be the appropriate cliche here. Nonetheless, it's not a bad dictum for government...

Saturday, January 03, 2015

Universal Credit: is it the theory or the practice that is bothering Rachel Reeves?

Featured on Liberal Democrat VoiceAccording to the Daily Telegraph, Iain Duncan-Smith is intending to accelerate the rollout of Universal Credit to thwart Rachel Reeves and her intention to pause its implementation.

This is odd, because Ms Reeves said that in June, after the Major Projects Authority and the Public Accounts Committee has noted their concerns with the project. They were probably right to, if the concern was simply over the cost of the project and the likelihood of the IT infrastructure working. However, it isn't clear to me whether or not a pause would lead to scrapping the project or not.

Universal Credit, not necessarily coming to a town near you soon...
Universal Credit, in conceptual terms, seems like a bit of a no-brainer. Bringing together the application processes of a number of benefits and rolling them into one would reduce the cost of bureaucracy and, perhaps ironically, making it more likely that some vulnerable people would receive benefits to which they were entitled but had not actually claimed, put off by the hassle of form filling and assessment. And, in theory, there is nothing that should prevent the creation of an IT system that would support it.

In practice, however, government is bad at big IT projects, poor on procurement, prone to mid-project interference and weak on deciding what it actually wants in the first place.

And so it has come to pass with Universal Credit. Ironically, one of the underpinning changes, the introduction by HM Revenue & Customs of Real Time Information for PAYE, seems to have gone quite smoothly, exposing the uncomfortable fact that any system requiring the analysis and processing of data is only as good as the data fed in. And some employers, it turns out, aren't very good at that.

Nonetheless, the Universal Credit programme has been delayed significantly, leading to a perceived loss of confidence that it will work.

But what is one to do? Scrapping the project takes you back to the drawing board, whereby you still need to find ways of cutting the cost of social security. And, if cutting the cost of administration is made more difficult, that means an increased likelihood that benefits themselves will need to be cut - not an attractive option for politicians who claim to want to protect the poor and the vulnerable.

So, Ms Reeves faces a dilemma. Does she continue to harbour public doubts about the viability of Universal Credit, does she openly support the concept, or does she oppose both process and concept? And time is ticking...

Wednesday, October 01, 2014

"Hey, mister, wanna buy a prepaid benefits card?"

The announcement at the Conservative Party Conference by Iain Duncan Smith that he is planning to initiate a pilot scheme whereby prepaid cards are given to benefit claimants instead of money is one of those slightly uncomfortable proposals that make me think, "On one hand...".

The idea that the prepaid cards could only be used for a restricted range of purchases is superficially appealing, especially if you are the sort of person who believes that people should be appropriately grateful for what they receive. Such a person, and there are many of them out there, would claim that the purpose of welfare benefits is to pay for "essentials", whatever that might mean. They might go on to mutter their discontent over those whose benefit payments appear to be converted into profit for the pub trade.

And there is a legitimate, if difficult, debate to be had here - what do we believe a benefits system is for? What level of provision are we trying to achieve, and do the recipients of that provision have some obligations in return?

So, when Iain Duncan-Smith says;
I have long believed that where parents have fallen into a damaging spiral – drug or alcohol addiction, even problem debt, or more – we need to find ways to safeguard them – and more importantly, their families, their children, ensuring their basic needs are met.
he sounds reasonable, indeed caring. The catch is that his aim is to reduce the social security bill, and he gives the impression that he doesn't care much about the impact of his decisions. Indeed, he often finds ways of taking quite good ideas and finding ways of making them punitive.

This is not necessarily one of those good ideas though, and other, more knowledgeable people than I have pointed out issues relating to technology and cost and inconvenience to retailers and their customers, not to mention the likely impact on market stalls or rural claimants. And, of course, that is before you turn to the moral and ethical implications of deciding what is appropriate to people for them.
 
As Liberal Democrats, we need to be extremely cautious about this. Finding new ways of targetting financial support more efficiently and preventing the emergence of perverse disincentives to seek paid work are inevitable if we are to get the best use out of government spending, yet stigmatising the poor and the vulnerable any more than their status already does runs contrary to our belief that preserving the dignity of human beings is part of ensuring that they are not enslaved by conformity or poverty.
 
Trusting the majority of people to act responsibly is surely the right thing to do, and restricting their freedom through state action is hardly encouraging anything other than increasingly resigned dependence on others to run their lives.
 
And, on the whole, when the technological and moral complexities of any course of Government action suggest that something is both difficult to deliver and unlikely to have much, if any, positive impact, my feeling is that it isn't worth doing at all.
 
Unless, of course, your aim is to make a gesture. You wouldn't do that, would you Mr Duncan-Smith?...

Monday, January 23, 2012

For the benefit of Iain Duncan-Smith: a definition of homelessness

This morning, on BBC's Breakfast Show, Iain Duncan-Smith was talking about the impact of his proposals on a benefit cap. He suggested that the 'scare stories' were exaggerated, claiming that the Shelter definition of homelessness was unrealistic.

Featured on Liberal Democrat VoiceWhen pressed, he stated that their definition of homelessness includes circumstances where bedrooms are being shared. At this point, Ros noted that he was being less than entirely accurate.

So, I thought that I ought to check. Given that Ros has plenty of knowledge on housing issues, and has held senior office at District and County level, I'd tend to trust her judgement. And here, for the benefit of the Secretary of State, is Shelter's actual definition;

"Homelessness means not having a home - most people who are homeless don't sleep on the street. Even if you have a roof over your head you can still be homeless. This is because you may not have any rights to stay where you live or your home might be unsuitable for you due to severe overcrowding or other reasons."

If I was being extremely generous, I would accept that he may have misinterpreted this. But I'm not. To my mind, most people would see severe overcrowding as being rather more than simply sharing a bedroom.

So, either he is wilfully misrepresenting the facts, or he is ignorant of them. And on that basis, he is unworthy of any faith that Parliamentarians might wish to place in his judgement. And that rather casts doubt on the quality of the legislation he is promoting...

Wednesday, November 02, 2011

Written ministerial statement on the Universal Credit Migration Strategy

Yesterday, the Government issued a statement on the timetable for the transition from the current welfare framework of multiple benefits to the new Universal Credit. 

"Today the Department for Work and Pensions announces its strategy for moving 12 million working-age benefit and credit recipients on to Universal Credit by 2017.

Universal Credit is intended to provide a streamlined welfare system which makes the financial advantages of taking work or increasing hours clear to claimants. We recognise that the move from one welfare system to another needs to be carefully managed to ensure social outcomes are maximised and no one is left without support.

The transition from the old benefit system to Universal Credit will therefore take place in three phases over four years, ending in 2017 with around 7.7 million households receiving more support to find more work and be more self-sufficient.

Between October 2013 and April 2014, 500,000 new claimants will receive Universal Credit in place of jobseeker's allowance, employment support allowance, housing benefit, Working Tax credit and Child Tax Credit. At the same time, a further 500,000 existing claimants (and their partners and dependants) will also move on to Universal Credit as and when their circumstances change significantly, such as when they find work or when a child is born.

From April 2014, the second phase will give priority to households who will benefit most from the transition, such as those Working Tax Credit claimants who currently work a small number of hours a week but could work more hours with the support that Universal Credit brings. Overall, 3.5 million existing claimants (and their partners and dependents) will be transferred on to Universal Credit during this second phase.

The last and final phase, which begins at the end of 2015 and runs through to the end of 2017, will see around three million households being transferred to Universal Credit by local authority boundary. This phase will have the flexibility to respond to the circumstances of particular local authorities as they change and will focus on safeguarding financial support, such as housing benefit payments, to claimants as the old benefit system winds down.

The Department for Work and Pensions will continue to work with HMRC and local authorities to settle on a precise timing schedule of the move to Universal Credit. Once agreed, the schedule will be kept under regular review."

Iain Duncan-Smith
Secretary of State, Work and Pensions

It must be borne in mind that this isn't the only big project underway at the moment, as HM Revenue & Customs are preparing to unleash 'Real Time Information', which will provide DWP with up to date information about claimants' employment income.

But, if it all works, it will reduce the administrative costs of our benefit system significantly, and make it easier for those eligible for benefits to get what they are entitled to.